InsightsAppeal decisions · 6 min read

A Grampian condition needs a realistic prospect: Oddfellows Street, Cleckheaton.

The High Court refused a challenge to the dismissal of 33 homes reached by a private street. The works relied on powers the council was unlikely to use.

Ripple Development PlanningPublished

High Court judgment: · Permission refused · [2026] EWHC 2474 (Admin)

An appeal for 33 homes in Cleckheaton was dismissed because the access street needed improving, and the works depended on the council using its private street works powers. The developer offered to pay for everything. The High Court refused permission to challenge the decision: paying for works is not the same as showing they will happen.

The case: John Lund v SSHCLG and Kirklees Metropolitan Borough Council [2026] EWHC 2474 (Admin)

The scheme: 33 homes on grassland off Oddfellows Street, Cleckheaton

Judge: Karen Ridge, sitting as a Deputy High Court Judge, Planning Court at Leeds

Decision: Permission to bring a section 288 challenge refused, 1 October 2026. The appeal decision of 23 December 2025 stands.

Read the judgment

The background

The site would be reached along Oddfellows Street, part of which is unadopted and unlit. Everyone agreed it was not adequate for the development without improvement, and the main issue at appeal was highway safety (judgment, paragraph 3).

The developer’s answer was a unilateral undertaking to cover, in effect, the whole cost of the works, with no commencement or occupation until they were complete, alongside a proposed Grampian condition (paragraphs 4 and 5). A Grampian condition prevents development until something outside the site has been done. Here the works would be delivered through the council’s private street works powers under sections 205 to 208 of the Highways Act 1980, which allow a highway authority to make up a private street and recover the cost from the frontage owners.

The frontage owners had opposed the works in a 2024 consultation, and the highway authority said it would not act against that opposition (paragraph 22). The inspector accepted that the powers existed and could in principle be used against unwilling owners. He found no prospect of them being used within the three years of a planning permission, so the development would have an unacceptable impact on highway safety (paragraph 6).

What the court decided

The parties agreed the test, taken from Planning Practice Guidance: a Grampian condition should not be imposed where there is no prospect at all of the action being taken within the life of the permission (paragraphs 9 and 12). All four grounds of challenge were found unarguable.

  1. Landowner objections were relevant. The developer argued that the owners’ objections were immaterial, relying on British Railways Board v SSE. The judge held that the argument “misunderstands the nature of the Inspector’s task” (paragraph 8). That case concerns the planning merits, not the practical prospect of a public body using its powers.
  2. The reasoning was consistent. The inspector moved from finding that delivery was uncertain to finding no prospect. The judge saw “the development of his reasoning, not a contradiction”, with reasons that were adequate and intelligible (paragraph 20).
  3. The undertaking did not bind the highway authority. The inspector accepted the scope of the powers; his concern was whether they would be used. The undertaking “did not compel the Highway Authority to act” (paragraph 23).
  4. No irrationality. The council’s willingness to explore options did not make the conclusion irrational. The judge described the claim as, in substance, an attempt to re-argue the planning merits (paragraphs 24 and 25).

The judge also observed that a planning authority cannot require the highway authority to use its powers (paragraph 15).

Why it matters

Many small and infill sites rely on an access that the developer does not control: an unadopted street, a lane with several frontage owners, or a splay over third party land. A Grampian condition is often the proposed solution, and the test for it is low. It is only where there is no prospect at all of the works happening that the condition fails.

This case shows that the test is about practical delivery, not legal possibility or funding. The powers existed, and the money was offered. What was missing was any realistic route to the highway authority deciding to use those powers in the face of local opposition (paragraphs 6 and 22).

Our view

The outcome was well founded on the evidence before the inspector. The highway authority had said it would not act against the frontage owners, and an inspector is entitled to take that at face value. The judgment does not say a private street works route can never support a Grampian condition. It says the inspector was entitled to find no prospect on these facts.

Two points of weight are worth keeping in view. This was a refusal of permission to bring a claim, not a full hearing, so the reasoning is brief. And the underlying finding is a planning judgment on the evidence, so a different record of the authority’s intentions could support a different conclusion.

What to take into the next scheme

  • Establish who controls the access early. Check adoption status, frontage ownership and any rights of way along the route before the layout is fixed.
  • Ask the highway authority about its powers. Where works depend on a council decision, seek its view on whether it would use the powers, and when, and record the answer.
  • Look for options within your control. Works on land the applicant controls, or with the owners’ written agreement, are easier to secure by condition.
  • Treat funding as necessary but not sufficient. An undertaking to pay does not oblige anyone else to act.
  • Address the three-year test directly. Set out the steps, approvals and timescale that make delivery realistic within the life of the permission.

Judgment and references

  1. John Lund v SSHCLG and Kirklees MBC [2026] EWHC 2474 (Admin), The National ArchivesBackground: paragraphs 1 to 6. The Grampian test: paragraphs 9 and 12. Ground 1: paragraphs 7 to 16. Ground 2: paragraphs 17 to 20. Ground 3: paragraphs 21 to 23. Ground 4: paragraphs 24 and 25. Outcome: paragraph 26.
  2. Planning Practice Guidance, Use of planning conditionsThe guidance on conditions requiring works on land outside the applicant’s control.
  3. Highways Act 1980, Part XI, Making up of private streetsSections 205 to 208, the private street works code.

Ripple was not involved in this case. Sources checked 18 November 2026. The project recommendations are our interpretation of the published judgment, not legal advice. Each proposal needs assessment on its own facts.

Related services: Highways conditions · Highways objections · Access and layout checks.

One useful email a month

Appeal decisions, policy changes and practical guidance on transport and planning, explained plainly. Unsubscribe at any time.

Keep reading

Related decisions and guidance.

All insights