InsightsAppeal decisions · 6 min read

Measured speeds and a short splay: the Haxted coach house appeal.

A coach house conversion on a 40 mph rural road was allowed. Surveyed speeds of 26 and 27 mph, a clean collision record and the access layout outweighed short splays.

Ripple Development PlanningPublished

Appeal decision: · Allowed · Appeal 6014559

A one-bedroom conversion of a coach house near Lingfield was refused because of the existing access onto Haxted Road and the site’s distance from services. The inspector allowed the appeal. The splays were short for a 40 mph road, but surveyed speeds were far lower, and the inspector weighed what was actually happening at the access.

The appeal: 6014559, The Coach House, Haxted Road, Haxted, Surrey

The scheme: Conversion of a coach house to a one-bedroom dwelling with garden and parking, using an existing shared access

Inspector: C Walker, written representations, site visit 11 November 2026

Decision: Allowed, 12 November 2026. Tandridge District Council application TA/2024/1247.

Read the decision

The background

Haxted Road is an unlit rural road with a 40 mph limit and no footways or wide verges near the site (decision, paragraph 5). The coach house sits in a small cluster of homes, about 1 kilometre from Lingfield (paragraph 4).

The site uses an existing access that already serves a handful of homes. A building on one side and a wall behind a narrow verge on the other limit the splays to 2.4 metres by 16 metres to the south and 2.4 metres by 20 metres to the north. No changes to the access were proposed (paragraph 9).

The council’s concern was the intensification of an access it considered substandard (paragraph 10). It also considered the site an unsuitable location for housing, given the walk to services along an unlit road.

What the inspector decided

  1. Location. Walking to bus stops around 565 and 585 metres away would be unrealistic and unsafe along this road, so occupiers would rely on the car. The site was not a suitable location for housing in accessibility terms (paragraphs 5 and 7).
  2. But the harm was limited. Because walking along the road was unlikely to happen, the inspector did not find unacceptable harm to pedestrians or cyclists. A single one-bedroom conversion would generate few trips, and a conversion offers little scope to change travel choices, so the conflict with policy was limited (paragraphs 7 and 8).
  3. Speed evidence. A seven-day survey recorded 85th percentile speeds of 26 mph southbound and 27 mph northbound. The inspector noted that no substantive evidence had been put forward on the splays required at those speeds, or the size of any shortfall (paragraph 10).
  4. The access worked in practice. Speeds were materially below the limit, the road was not heavily trafficked, and there was no on-street parking blocking views. Tracking drawings showed the straight access drive could take two cars passing. No personal injury collisions had been recorded near the access in five years (paragraphs 13 to 15).
  5. Conclusion on access. One more modest dwelling would not be materially harmful to highway safety. There was no conflict with Local Plan Policy DP5 or with Framework Policy TR6 (paragraph 16).

In the planning balance, the inspector gave substantial weight to the housing contribution, with the council’s supply at 2.49 years, and to a 70% improvement in the building’s energy performance. The Framework’s support for re-using existing buildings also weighed in favour (paragraphs 18 to 24). A condition requires the visibility zones on the approved plan to be kept clear of anything over 0.6 metres high (condition 3).

The TRICS evidence

The appellant’s TRICS assessment compared the claimed storage use with the proposed dwelling and predicted one fewer vehicle trip over a 12-hour weekday. The inspector gave it only limited weight (paragraph 12). It used a commercial warehouse category and edge of town sites, while the appeal site is distinctly rural, and the same locational assumptions applied to the dwelling. The planning status of the storage use had also not been evidenced (paragraph 11).

The appeal succeeded on the access evidence, not the trip comparison.

Why it matters

Many rural conversions and small infill schemes rely on an existing access with splays that look short against the posted limit. This decision shows the weight an inspector can give to measured speeds, observed conditions, the layout of the access itself and the collision record, where they point the same way.

It also shows that a fallback trip comparison needs to stand up. A TRICS selection that does not match the site’s location, or an existing use that is not evidenced, may attract little weight.

Our view

The decision follows a familiar approach: splays are judged against the speeds drivers actually travel, not the speed limit alone. The surveyed speeds here were well below the limit, and that was the foundation for the conclusion on access.

Two limits on its reach are worth noting. This was a single dwelling on an access already used by several homes, so the increase in use was small. And the outcome turned on site-specific evidence, including the inspector’s own observations, that will differ elsewhere. A splay calculation set against the surveyed speed would have made the comparison explicit for both parties.

What to take into the next scheme

  • Survey speeds early. A seven-day survey at the access gives 85th percentile speeds in each direction to design from.
  • Show the required splay. Set out the splay needed for the surveyed speeds alongside what is available, so the shortfall, if any, is clear.
  • Check the collision record. Five years of personal injury collision data near the access is simple to obtain and was given weight here.
  • Evidence any existing use. A fallback comparison needs proof of the lawful use, and TRICS sites that match the location.
  • Deal with accessibility honestly. For a small conversion, explain the limited trip numbers and the policy support for re-using buildings, rather than overstating walking routes.

Judgment and references

  1. Appeal decision 6014559, The Coach House, Haxted Road, Planning InspectorateLocation and accessibility: paragraphs 4 to 8. Access and splays: paragraph 9. Speed survey: paragraph 10. TRICS: paragraphs 11 and 12. Highway safety: paragraphs 13 to 16. Planning balance: paragraphs 17 to 24. Visibility condition: paragraph 27 and condition 3.

Ripple was not involved in this appeal. Sources checked 18 November 2026. The project recommendations are our interpretation of the published decision, not legal advice. Each proposal needs assessment on its own facts.

Related services: Access and layout checks · Automatic traffic counts · Highways objections.

One useful email a month

Appeal decisions, policy changes and practical guidance on transport and planning, explained plainly. Unsubscribe at any time.

Keep reading

Related decisions and guidance.

All insights